Contrast: Programmatic SFA Bio (Treated), Non-Programmatic SFA Bio (Control)

Treatment Cases:
202
Control Cases:
804

Figure 1. Mean Estimated Impacts from Causal Tree and Random Forest Estimation Strategies.

In this illustration, the blue vertical line is the global estimate of impact from the random forest. The range of uncertainty is illustrated using a histogram, indicating the proportion of simulations which result in positive or negative estimates. Specific confidence intervals can be calculated for this global estimate, or for individual project locations. A map of project location uncertainties is presented below.

Descriptive Statistics for Programmatic SFA Bio (Treated)
StatisticMeanSt. Dev.MinMedianMax
Dist. to Rivers (m)214,506.701,575,601.00889.022,124.2715,768,872.00
Dist. to Roads (m)34,399.07149,847.60297.853,323.371,293,215.00
Elevation (m)589.63845.74-0.20314.044,687.19
Slope (degrees)3.604.890.001.2223.31
Urb. Dist. (rel)579.04771.0916.22313.153,877.55
Pop. Density (2000)234.61404.480.1365.532,763.53
Protected Area %66.85103.350.000.66384.74
Treecover (2000, %)29.9433.540.0016.0999.73
Latitude17.4915.64-21.3516.0249.16
Longitude58.2160.33-169.9690.49171.15
Max Precip. (2002, mm)246.81150.1331.90214.801,035.42
Min Precip (2002, mm)13.8128.170.003.52182.80
Mean Precip (2002, mm)99.0262.054.2294.29321.83
Max Temp (2002, C)25.954.847.7527.1036.70
Min Temp (2002, C)11.9614.09-28.6020.1026.90
Mean Temp (2002, C)19.388.28-7.9423.5729.28
Nightime Lights (2002, Relative)3.977.630.000.2540.07
NDVI (2002, Unitless)1,985.07820.74394.971,933.933,993.96
Programmatic SFA Bio1.000.00111
2013 Forest Cover (Sq. km)4.429.890.000.4176.78
Propensity Model: Programmatic SFA Bio (Treated), Non-Programmatic SFA Bio (Control)
Dependent variable:
treatment
Dist. to Rivers (m)0.0000** (0.0000, 0.0000)
Dist. to Roads (m)0.0000 (-0.0000, 0.0000)
Elevation (m)0.0000 (-0.001, 0.001)
Slope (degrees)-0.21*** (-0.30, -0.12)
Urb. Dist. (rel)0.001*** (0.0004, 0.001)
Pop. Density (2000)-0.0003 (-0.001, 0.0004)
Protected Area %-0.01*** (-0.01, -0.004)
Treecover (2000, %)0.03*** (0.01, 0.04)
Latitude0.02 (-0.01, 0.05)
Longitude0.03*** (0.02, 0.03)
Max Precip. (2002, mm)-0.003 (-0.01, 0.001)
Min Precip (2002, mm)-0.03*** (-0.05, -0.02)
Mean Precip (2002, mm)0.01 (-0.01, 0.02)
Max Temp (2002, C)0.44*** (0.12, 0.75)
Min Temp (2002, C)0.49*** (0.23, 0.74)
Mean Temp (2002, C)-0.88*** (-1.43, -0.33)
Nightime Lights (2002, Relative)-0.02 (-0.06, 0.03)
NDVI (2002, Unitless)-0.001*** (-0.001, -0.0005)
Constant0.13 (-3.28, 3.54)
Observations875
Akaike Inf. Crit.548.91
Note:*p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01
Percent Balance Improvement:
Mean Diff.eQQ MedeQQ MeaneQQ Max
Propensity Score80.24781.63480.17880.365
Dist. to Rivers (m)-21.77622.010-43.363-4.543
Dist. to Roads (m)-11.89489.864-17.434-9.890
Elevation (m)32.073-96.79021.2527.364
Slope (degrees)54.78259.29945.58825.084
Urb. Dist. (rel)59.17079.08540.443-28.452
Pop. Density (2000)82.11083.50532.7030
Protected Area %61.42388.83957.28334.890
Treecover (2000, %)68.25512.43522.49828.912
Latitude74.95366.16251.56844.276
Longitude96.68372.00266.81522.035
Max Precip. (2002, mm)62.915-11.806-2.05130.508
Min Precip (2002, mm)-11.51849.9009.393-25.686
Mean Precip (2002, mm)42.13141.32836.59570.114
Max Temp (2002, C)87.68369.19462.1520
Min Temp (2002, C)93.46744.70550.17028.623
Mean Temp (2002, C)89.60560.69459.52040.169
Nightime Lights (2002, Relative)79.49984.25842.87365.910
NDVI (2002, Unitless)78.64943.90637.6514.602
Matched Model: Programmatic SFA Bio (Treated), Non-Programmatic SFA Bio (Control)
Dependent variable:
2013 Forest Cover (Sq. km)
treatment-0.04 (-0.17, 0.10)
Dist. to Rivers (m)-0.40 (-1.62, 0.82)
Dist. to Roads (m)-0.08 (-0.49, 0.32)
Elevation (m)-0.05 (-0.35, 0.26)
Slope (degrees)-0.21* (-0.44, 0.01)
Urb. Dist. (rel)-0.05 (-0.20, 0.10)
Pop. Density (2000)-0.03 (-0.24, 0.18)
Protected Area %-0.22*** (-0.35, -0.09)
Treecover (2000, %)0.25** (0.04, 0.47)
Latitude0.17 (-0.30, 0.63)
Longitude0.16 (-0.05, 0.36)
Max Precip. (2002, mm)0.13 (-0.22, 0.49)
Min Precip (2002, mm)-0.01 (-0.21, 0.18)
Mean Precip (2002, mm)-0.14 (-0.61, 0.33)
Max Temp (2002, C)-0.93** (-1.76, -0.11)
Min Temp (2002, C)-1.07 (-2.83, 0.69)
Mean Temp (2002, C)1.97* (-0.33, 4.27)
Nightime Lights (2002, Relative)-0.09 (-0.27, 0.10)
NDVI (2002, Unitless)0.13 (-0.04, 0.30)
Urb. Dist. (rel) *Treatment-0.18** (-0.32, -0.03)
Dist. to Rivers (m) *Treatment0.49 (-0.73, 1.71)
Dist. to Roads (m) *Treatment0.06 (-0.35, 0.46)
Pop. Density (2000) *Treatment0.08 (-0.09, 0.24)
Latitude *Treatment-0.002 (-0.45, 0.45)
Longitude *Treatment-0.07 (-0.28, 0.14)
NDVI (2002, Unitless) *Treatment0.03 (-0.12, 0.18)
Elevation (m) *Treatment0.25* (-0.05, 0.55)
Slope (degrees) *Treatment-0.03 (-0.22, 0.17)
Mean Temp (2002, C) *Treatment0.44 (-0.49, 1.37)
Min Temp (2002, C) *Treatment-0.34 (-1.43, 0.74)
Max Precip. (2002, mm) *Treatment-0.19 (-0.54, 0.15)
Mean Precip (2002, mm) *Treatment0.07 (-0.37, 0.51)
Min Precip (2002, mm) *Treatment-0.003 (-0.20, 0.19)
Protected Area % *Treatment0.10 (-0.03, 0.23)
Constant0.004 (-0.13, 0.14)
Observations254
R20.33
Adjusted R20.22
Note:*p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01

Standardized Beta Coefficients for Linear Model with Heterogeneous Effects